The following is list of the Managers that have lead Indy Eleven clubs (men's and women's) through their history, starting with their inaugural coach Juergen Sommer in the NASL days to the present. Click on each coach for their biography.
NASL
- Juergen Sommer (June 11, 2013 - June 2, 2015
- Tim Regan (June 2, 2015 - December 1, 2015) - As Interim Head Coach
- Tim Hankinson (December 2, 2015 - November 28, 2017)
USL Championship
- Martin Rennie (January 16, 2018 - June 16, 2021)
- Max Rogers (June 16, 2021 - November 15, 2021) - As Interim Head Coach
- Mark Lowry (November 16, 2021 - November 28, 2023)
- Sean McAuley (January 8, 2024 - present)
USL W League
- Paul Dolinsky (December 14, 2021 - June 30, 2024)
- Brandon Kim (June 30, 2024 - present) - As Interim Head Coach
