The following is a list of players that have reached 100 games with Indy Eleven, as well as a running list of the supporters inducted into the XI Century Club (list obtained from Indy Eleven Twitter post and Century Club member emails).
Don Smart "Mr. Indy"
- First Game - April 12, 2014 vs Carolina Railhawks
- 100th Game - October 21, 2017 at Puerto Rico FC
- Final Game - October 29, 2017 vs Carolina Railhawks
- 101 Games Played (61 Games Started)
Brad Ring "Legend"
- First Game - April 12, 2014 vs Carolina Railhawks
- 100th Game - May 11, 2018 vs Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC
- Final Game - September 22, 2018 at Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC
- 115 Games Played (95 Games Started)
Karl Ouimette "Beans"
- First Game - March 24, 2018 @ Richmond Kickers
- 100th Game - September 18, 2021 vs Louisville City FC
- Final Game - March 26, 2022 at Louisville City FC
- 108 Games Played (101 Games Started)
Ayoze García Pérez "Ayo"
- First Game - April 7, 2018 @ North Carolina FC
- 100th Game - October 23, 2021 vs FC Tulsa
- Final Game - October 12, 2022 vs Birmingham Legion
- 126 Games Played (106 Games Started)
- Recognized on 10/23/2021 vs FC Tulsa
- More than 180 Members (some supporters have info on roles they have held in club history)
- Hector Aguilar
- Jason Alexander
- Cheryl Badale
- David Beery
- Jerome Boldt
- Robin Boldt
- Timothy Boldt
- Mark Brimmer
- Justin Brinker
- Dave Brokaw
- Becca Brown
- Garrett Brown
- Nancy Brown - Leader of the Brickyard Battalion's WARHEADS drumline; Slaughterhouse-19 Matron Saint
- Ray Bruck
- Betsy Butz
- Zachary Byrd
- Kelli Capone
- Tony Capone
- Shaun Carter
- John Chope - Slaughterhouse-19 Patron Saint
- Gary Clark
- Amy Clarkson
- Scott Clarkson
- Rufus Cochran
- Brandon Cockrum - Writer of the site Brew Wallace
- Matthew Conroy
- Mark Copple
- Benjamin Corbett
- Judith Corbit
- Gina Corsaro
- Zach Cramer
- Scott Crowe
- Brian Culver
- Neil Curry
- Mel Denaro
- Frank Dixon
- Tyler Drake
- Michael Dugan
- Monika Dunmore
- Tom Dunmore - Indy Eleven front office staff
- Gary Edwards
- David Eli
- Monte Ellis
- Abby Evans
- Peter Evans - Slaugherhouse-19 & BYB Presidents; Slaughterhouse-19 Patron Saint
- Jason Flora
- Steve Fon
- Leia Foster
- William Foster
- Daniel Frank
- Robert French
- Tara Fro
- Pat Gammon
- Amy Gibson
- Andrea Grotenhuis
- Todd Grotenhuis
- Jim Gutting
- Frank Hall
- Lorraine Hall
- Suzanne Harris
- Brad Hauter - TV Color Commentator
- Tony Hebenstreit
- Caitlyn Hempstead
- Greg Hempstead
- Norah Hempstead
- Sarah Hempstead
- Michael Henn - Indy Eleven front office staff
- Trey Higdon - Indy Eleven front office staff
- Holden Hill
- Evan Himes
- Dolores Hoyt
- Giles Hoyt
- Kevin Huff
- Kylene Huff
- Alan Huffman
- Cindy Huffman
- Deanna Huggins
- Mike Huggins
- Tim Huggins
- Jeff Hultman
- Brandon Jett - Indy Eleven front office staff
- Rachel Jett
- Sandy Jett
- Jim Johnson
- Brandon Jones
- Patrick Kelly
- Andrew Kidwell
- Tom Klassen
- Donna Knight
- Paul Knight
- John Koluder - Indy Eleven front office staff
- Karen Kolvert
- Frank Konermann
- Hailey Konermann
- Daniel Kovert
- Chuck Krupa
- Greg Lacy
- Gregory Ladd
- Josh Lauritsen
- Tian Liang - Indy Eleven front office staff
- Edward Liechty
- Larry Linde - Indy Eleven front office staff
- David Loncaric
- Hayley Loncaric
- Jennifer Loncaric
- Thomas Longest
- John Louie
- Linda Louie
- Joyce Lucke
- Bryan Macer
- Michael Maddox
- Brian Maloney
- Josh Mariano - BYB Vice President, Slaughtehouse-10 Patron Saint
- Tracy Mariano - Slaughterhouse-19 Matron Saint
- Vincen Mariano - Slaughterhouse-19 Patron Saint
- Josh Mason - BYB President & Indy Eleven front office staff
- Oliver Mason
- Deatra McKeeman
- Everett McKeeman
- Robbie Mehling - photographer for SocTakes
- Patrick Miller
- JR Montoya
- Chad Moon
- Don Moore
- Michael Mueller
- Todd Neal
- Josh Needler
- Ken Niese
- Mike Obremski
- Maureen Owen
- Jane Parker
- George Perry
- Isaac Peterson
- Thomas Peterson
- Travis Phelps - Recognized during the game as having attended 154 games!
- Adrienne Qualls
- Greg Rakestraw - TV play-by-play
- Caleb Ramp
- Susan Reck
- Elliott Reed
- Katherine Reed - BYB President (first female); Slaughterhouse-19 Matron Saint
- Andrew Retz - BYB President
- Shane Rice
- Michael Richardson
- Ryan Richeson
- Tara Richeson
- Tom Roederer
- Doug Ryner
- Elizabeth Sabato
- Jose Sandoval
- Jessica Sandoval
- Amelia Smith
- Andrew Smith
- Chris Smith
- Val Spangler
- Will Spangler
- Derek Sprunger
- Duane Stahl
- William Stanton
- Lauren Stark
- William Stark - BYB Secretary, Slaughterhouse-19 Patron Saint
- Chris Steadman
- Rich Stein
- Jason Stroup
- Jeni Stroup
- Patrick Sullivan
- Bart Taylor - Founder/President of City of Firsts BYB; capo
- Carin Taylor
- Therron Thomas
- Vernetta Thomas
- Andrew Thompson - Founder, writer, & editor of this site (The Game Beckons)
- Bruce Thompson
- Don Thompson - Photographer for this site (The Game Beckons)
- Michelle Tubbs
- Diane VanOsdol
- Michael VanOsdol
- Regina Vittorio
- Nathaniel Wagner
- Thomas Watchel
- Justin Wiese
- Michael Withers
- Janet Withers
- Alex Wolfe
- Erick Young
- Amir Zaid
Second Induction Class of Supporters - Recognized 08/06/2022 vs Pittsburgh Riverhounds
- Chris Blackburn
- Chad Bobb
- Garrett Brown
- Jarron Burdine
- Matthew Conroy
- Dave DuPlantis
- Rod Eidsness
- Ben Fulton
- Ryan Garner
- Gabe Granger
- Jim Hertel
- Justin Hill
- Jim Johnson
- Brandon Jones
- Jake Keefer
- Patrick Kelly
- Andrew Kidwell
- Hailey Konermann
- Frank Konermann
- Daniel Kovert
- Karen Kovert
- Chuck Krupa
- Greg Lacy
- Josh Lauritsen - has an Indy Eleven tattoo based on game day poster by supporter Laura Mills
- Edward Liechty
- Denise Mueller
- John Newbold
- Caroline Noble
- Chris Noble
- Mark Quertinmont
- Maya Rice
- Noah Rice
- Jack Robling
- Jeff Roeder
- Joseph Silverberg
- Erik Skoog
- Marty Spicer
- Chris Steadham
- Brandon Thompson
- Debbie Thompson - Photographer for this site (The Game Beckons)
- Marc Wilson
- Libby Young
- Grant Walker
Fourth Induction Class of Supporters - Recognized 10/19/2024 vs Birmingham Legion FC
- Alejandro Agustin
- Ben Agustin
- Kasey Agustin
- Erik Albers
- Josh Baker
- Christopher Blackburn
- Lyle Boldt
- Ethan Caffee
- Scott Cashion
- David Ciskowski
- Donald Clark Jr.
- JR Denney
- Declan Doyle
- Dave DuPlantis
- Rod Eidsness
- Ben Fulton
- Josh Gantt
- Samantha Gantt
- Ryan Garner
- Angela Goldenetz
- Bradley Goshen
- Gabriel Granger
- Sabrina Hardimon-Collins
- Maurice Henein
- Derek Herbert
- Jim Hertel
- Justin Hill
- Blake Hooper
- Andy Hunnicutt
- Jim Johnson
- Brandon Jones
- Thomas Keefer
- Patrick Kelly
- Aaron Kidwell
- Andrew Kidwell
- Frank Konermann
- Geoffrey Mahan
- Zach McNulty
- Jeff Milliken
- Robert Myrehn
- John Newbold
- David Orr
- Mark Quertinmont
- Jeffrey Quyle
- Jack Robling
- Jeff Roeder
- David Rosenfield
- Tim Schlichte
- Gregory Schmarr
- Eric Schutte
- Traci Shaw
- Andrew Shilling
- Joseph Silverberg
- Erik Skoog
- Jacob Smalley
- Scott Thompson
- Charles Turk
- Grant Walker
- Mark Warner
- Marc Wilson
- John Winter
- Jason Wyrick
- Libby Young